The Vitals
Years Played: 12
Career Stat Line (pts/reb/ast/stl/blk/fg%/ft%) : 18.1 / 7.5 / 2.5 / 1.0 / 0.7 / 47% / 81%
Career Value Over Fantasy Replacement Player (VOFRP): 60.3
Career VOFRP (Game Adjusted): 58.1
Highest Fantasy Rank in a Season: 11th (1998-99).
Highest Fantasy Rank in a Season (on the All-Time list): 533
(my comments below in case you want to vote first)
The Bias
Abdur-Rahim has to be the poster child for good players who are stuck on bad teams. After being drafted by the Grizzles in 1996, he moved on to the Hawks in 2001, followed by the Blazers and finally the Kings (where he made the playoffs for the first time in his career… in 2006).
With post moves and a solid jumper, Abdur-Rahim came fully loaded with very good all-around offensive game. HoopsHype called him a “fake master” – but he could also do a little of this back in the day. In addition, Abdur-Rahim was money in the bank when it came to percentages, he finished his career shooting 47% from the floor and 81% from the line. It was too bad his defense was never quite up to the same standards.
Like our first HOF nominee, Chris Webber, Abdur-Rahim’s knees told him it was time to quit playing the game. Somewhat unlike Webber (in my opinion anyway), his career doesn’t scream HOF. He was very good for a long time, but even in his best year in 1998-99, he was not a top-10 fantasy player. His best season puts him at 533 on the all-time list, which is about 450 spots below Chris Webber’s peak. His game adjusted VOFRP is a very good 58.1, but it came from a sustained 10 year stretch of being a solid 2nd-4th round pick rather than any kind of fantasy dominance.

With Webber’s fantasy hall of fame induction looking unlikely, Shareef Abdur-Rahim’s chances of making the fantasy HOF seem about as good as his chances of making the real thing.